Get Along strawberry shortcake doughnut
Joel Davis’ Union coffee shop closed at Pickford’s Counter over the summer, but there’s a sweet side to the bad news, and that’s Get Along, a doughnut company where Davis leans on baker, recording engineer and skateboarder Asher Lakes plus Library Coffeehouse co-founder Marie Cullinan who help run the show. The shop—set to eventually open in Seminole Heights—has been doing pop ups, and if you can get your mouth around one of its strawberry shortcake concoctions, then you might petition decision makers in Plant City to make the sweet treats mandatory at their spring festival. @getalongtpa on Instagram
Burnz
Bern’s Steak House is a rite of passage in the Tampa dining scene, but now so is Burnz, just two miles north on Howard Avenue. There’s no wine room at the West Tampa restaurant, but there are Caribbean, Hispanic & American plates in a setting that’s definitely less velvet-y than the Bern’s reception). So next time you’re planning a date night, tell your partner , “We’re going to Burnz, baby.” burnzrbg.com
Peachey’s
It’s the fair food treat that I still think about daily: Peachey’s fresh and warm glazed yeast donut topped with a mountain of coconut cream pie filling, whipped cream and coconut shavings. It was big enough to share, but I didn’t want to. Peachey’s (FKA The Amish Baking Company) gets out of Florida during the super warm months, but should be back in Sarasota by November. @peacheysbakingco on Instagram
Café Gala at The Dalí
"Van Gogh Alive” at The Dalí was the most popular art exhibit Tampa Bay’s hosted in a long time. I had to book an appointment a month in advance to see it, and I’m an arts writer. But as much as I loved the exhibit, it’s not locally made. And it will probably be mostly the same no matter where in the world one sees it. But the Dalí did add a few personal touches that made the experience special for me. My favorites were the vases of sunflowers decorating the tables at Cafe Gala and Chuck Bandel’s Van Gogh-themed charcuterie board. Bandel’s pairing of Dutch cheese with a sunflower seed bar and a roasted pear was absolutely delightful. Before we dug in, I snapped a photo of our art snack next to a vase of sunflowers that would make most any art-lover think of Van Gogh. thedali.org
Xtreme Tacos Seminole Heights stoner burrito
In 2017, Crave Digital founder Chris Fasick, named the Xtreme Tacos Stoner Burrito the “Best Burritos That Need Their Own Blankets and Birth Certificates.” I didn’t think it was possible, but the baby-sized burrito is now stuffed with even more protein, rice, beans, french fries, thinly shredded cabbage, pico de gallo, sour cream, guacamole, and shredded cheese. I’m a 36-year-old, 6-foot, 200-pound human, and this thing literally stretched from my fingertips past my elbow. This thing doesn’t just need a birth certificate anymore, it needs vaccines so it can go to preschool. xtremetacos.com
Winner: Beach Blonde Ale by 3 Daughters
Runners-Up: Jai Alai at Cigar City, Postcard Pilsner at Green Bench
Stone Soup Co. V Stone Soup Cafe
CL Best of the Bay Readers Picks have always been tough to win, but it’s even harder when your business’ name is very similar to other one. Just as Ybor City’s Stone Soup Company and Stone Soup Cafe & Pub in St. Pete. Readers always got them mixed up, therefore fudging up numbers… and I’m thinking out loud now, but maybe the 2022 voting item should just ask readers to choose the “Best Stone Soup restaurant in Tampa Bay.” xsoup4u.com and stonesoupcafe.com
Babushka’s
At this tiny little restaurant in a tiny little Temple Terrace strip mall, don’t fret about when certain courses of your meal will come out. The plates arrive at the table when they’re ready, and who cares? The borscht, dumplings, and other Russian goodies are like a warm hug from a tiny little grandma, aka Babushka. babushkas.us
Jamison B Bakehouse
One of the only silver lining of COVID was Jamison B Bakehouse pivoting from restaurants to selling bread bags. For $40, you got three loaves (or two and a pack of pretzels, bagels) and a box of pastries, all designed at the whims of the bread gods. In the mood for fig and olive bread? Pumpernickel sauerkraut? Guava hand pies? With each day of the pandemic feeling the same, the weekly surprise of treats was a godsend. With the menu to view online, you can even add more treats (get the focaccia pizza) to pick up on Saturdays at 2 p.m. jamisonb.org
Raw Smoothie Co. Rise N Grind
Most everyone who gets in their car before 9 a.m. on the weekdays and gives half a rat’s ass about their health has a smoothie shop where they regularly spend disposable income. Mine is the OG storefront for this Tampa shop where the “Rise & Grind” (banana, espresso beans, peanut butter, cacao, honey, almond milk) not only keeps me full when I forget to bring my lunch to work, but inspires me to try and take better care of my body (read: skip the quarter-pounder, or ramen) day in and day out. rawsmoothieco.com
Supernatural Food & Wine
But not every breakfast is super-loaded with nutrients made to stoke the fire that is your body’s metabolism. Some breakfasts are meant to make your heart content, and that’s what SuperNatural’s “plain” cider sourdonut does for me. It’s spiced perfectly, and puffed at different volumes depending on the weather outside (kind of like me), with just a touch of salt to wake the senses. The best part, though, is that the vegan creation is served with the doughnut hole on the side, because it takes filling a hole to make you whole sometimes. supernaturalfoodandwine.square.site
Winner: Devon Kreps at 7venth Sun
Runners-Up: Wayne Wambles at Cigar City , Adam Deimling at Dunedin BreweryKing State turns two
To quote Forrest Gump, “I’m not a smart man, but I know what love is.” And while I’m no coffee, beer or wine expert, what I love is watching this neighborhood coffee shop and bar bring people together (masked for the most part, too) over the last two years. To celebrate its anniversary, the King State crew released special beer but also a collaboration with winemaker Subject to Change. The chillable blend (50% zinfandel with sauvignon blanc and syrah) is surprisingly effervescent and super crushable, and at just over $20 a bottle, not something I can get every day, meaning the King State “Red wine” (I think I heard someone call it “Bruce juice” in a nod to the shop’s alligator mascot) is something I put to my lips whenever I need a treat or reminder to take life more slowly. king-state.com
Coppertail’s Florida Special lager
Football stadiums are where corporate light beers are as abundant as oxygen, but there’s a breath of fresh air at Raymond James thanks to the Bucs’ new partnership with local brewing favorite Coppertail, which has crafted a “Florida Special Lager,” packaged all pretty in a 16-oz. creamsicle-colored tallboy complete a Bucco Bruce stamp on the side. And if you can’t afford a ticket to the game, get the beer at Publix. coppertailbrewing.com
Bae’s Burgers & Wings
With its name, location along Nebraska Avenue north of Busch, and hot-pink neon sign atop blacked-out windows, you could be forgiven for mistaking Bae’s for yet another gentlemen’s club—but step inside and you’ll find a menu with some of the best burgers in town and walls decorated with hundreds of photos illustrating Tampa Bay history shot by longtime Tribune photojournalist Fred Bellet. baesfreshfastfood.com
Wild Child jerk octopus
Chef Rob Reinsmith‘s jerk octopus has justly become one of Wild Child’s signature dishes. The accents of charred scallion crema, wafer-thin circles of fennel, small peeled grapefruit segments, red watercress leaves, sliced rings of pickled sweet peppers, and a spritz of fresh lime juice meld beautifully on the plate. The tentacles are firm without being rubbery and have just the right amount of heat to pop without throwing the dish out of balance. You’ll swoon like you’re in Spain. wildchildstpete.com
Jeannie Pierola
Chef Pierola has a storied history in the Tampa Restaurant scene. I missed her halcyon days at SideBerns, but her edison: food + drink lab is well up in my Top 50. However, she’s outdone herself with Counter Culture celebrating “interactive foodie culture” in a “bold and beautiful modern” setting. My rave review appeared with her on the CL cover the week the bottom fell out of our world as the pandemic sent the globe into lockdown. She took advantage to do some reno at edison and managed to keep Counter Culture afloat. I still dream of the yellowfin tuna wrapped toro tartare. cc-tampa.com and edison-tampa.com
Nathan Hardin
You didn’t have to grow up on Skyline Chili, to know that Nathan Hardin’s Cincinnati Chili was freaking delicious. But I did, and his popup at Pickford’s Counter made the Southern Ohio treat so yummy and high-quality that you didn’t regret your decision an hour later. Hardin also created a vegan version, which was missing in my imperfect-vegetarian life. @nathanlhardin on Instagram
Winner: Clear Sky on Cleveland
Runners-Up: Frenchy's Original Cafe, Mana Mana Middle Eastern Restaurant
Meacham Urban Farm
On a spit of dirt between the highway and a former housing project in the middle of Tampa, there’s an idyllic paradise. Something is growing over every square inch: strawberries tumbling over the curb, chamomile coming through sidewalk cracks. The atmosphere is absolutely serene, with babies running amongst tomatoes and a donut you can pay for with a smile (or Venmo.) Someone will hand you a sample of pickled veg with a spice you never hear of on top, and for a moment, you’ll forget that you’re in the wild, brutal world of Central Florida. Florida, thinking instead, it’s Eden. meachamfarm.com
Winner: Dunedin Craft Beer & Food Festival
Runners-Up: Tampa Bay Beer Week , Dunedin Brewery OktobeerfestWinner: Brocato's Sandwich Shop
Runners-Up: La Teresita Restaurant, West Tampa Sandwich ShopSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Bassano Cheesecake
Runners-Up: Mazzaro's Italian Market , Harry Waugh Dessert Room at Bern’s Steak HouseWinner: St. Petersburg Distillery
Runners-Up: Urban Stillhouse by Horse Soldier, Dark Door Spirits
Angry Chair “Ghost Light”
When the pandemic is unkind to your friends, you punch back, and that’s what Seminole Heights’ Angry Chair Brewing did for Ybor City venue Orpheum (which has hosted Angry Chair beek week release events). This spring, the brewery put out “Ghost Light,” a decadent imperial oatmeal chocolate stout with hints of toasted coconut brewed to help Orpheum, quite frankly, keep the ghost light on while the venue went dark. Orpheum is still around (and asking patrons to mask up), while Angry Chair has new plans to move into a bigger brewery, so karma was good them. angrychairbrewing.com
Filet mignon burrito at Red Mesa
Burritos are so intrinsically scrumptious that it’s hard to elevate one from another. Red Mesa—one of the Bay area’s most consistently excellent restaurants for over 20 years—has more than managed the feat. The key is replacing the ground beef (or pork or chicken) with delicate chunks of filet, which is never anything but melt-in-your-mouth juicy and tender. The meat joins a sublime blend of monterey jack cheese, poblano pepper, onion, red pepper and tomato. It’s well worth the $25 for a burrito this outstanding. Comes with black beans and cilantro rice. redmesarestaurant.com
Winner: John’s Pass Seafood Festival
Runners-Up: Taste of Dunedin , Safety Harbor Seafood and Art FestivalWinner: Gigglewaters
Runners-Up: Salty Sisters Gourmet Popcorn , Harley's Gourmet Popcorn and Cider ShoppeWinner: Casa Tina '"Fresh, Healthy, Authentic Mexican"
Runners-Up: Besito Mexican , Red Mesa CantinaGrand Cathedral Cigars
All you need to do is look at the parking lot (and overflow parking) on any given night to know that people love going to church at Grand Cathedral. The 21-and-up spot is owner Angela Yue’s totally renovated holy house of cigars complete with a piano bar, lounge, conference area, and a 6,000-square-foot outside event space—koi pond included. In a neighborhood where developers look to build architecturally ugly multi-unit housing on every available lot, GCC is an aesthetic wonder, and that’s not just the smoke in your eyes. grandcathedralcigars.com
Bula Kavananda (Seminole Heights)
Whether you go to Bula for kava, kratom or a fancy coffee made from mushrooms, the place is like hanging in a really clean and stylish friend’s house that smells of expensive incense. It has a daybed, workstations, and all around boho-chic comfiness that makes you want to stay for a while and forget both how messy your house is and how badly you need a new couch. bulakavananda.com
Winner: The Vinoy Renaissance St. Petersburg
Runners-Up: Fenway Hotel, HiFi Rooftop Bar , Elevage at Epicurean HotelThe spreads sampler at Baba
It is inevitable that you will be tempted by the daily hummus special at Baba’s, and you will never, ever be disappointed, because Baba’s hummus is the creamiest, most craveable concoction on the planet whether they add fried cauliflower or red peppers or even pork belly to the mix. But don’t forget you can get three of Baba’s delicious spreads in a sampler serving, with not just hummus but labneh, muhammara, tzatziki and more to choose from, all as tasty as their names are musical and accompanied by puffy, warm pita or fresh veggies. eatatbaba.com
Mays Alreem USA pita house
The war for most densely packed food options on one street rages on. Is it Armenia Avenue with all its South American, Caribbean, and Latin food ways? Or Waters Avenue, which takes you on a tour of Southeast Asia? My pick right now would be Mays Alreem on 56th Street just north of Fowler Avenue. Expect a no frills beef shwarma all wrapped in a pita with all the fixings, but make sure not to miss almost everything else on the menu. Falafel is balled and fried to order, offering that delicate, light, fluffy interior so many fail to get right. But the real winner here is the hummus and baba ghanouj. The oh so creamy hummus comes spooned and flattened on a paper plate, topped with chickpeas, olive oil, parsley, a garlic and parsley pesto of sorts, and finished with a generous sprinkling of sumac. It might be one of the prettiest dishes in Tampa at the moment… without the dish. Baba ghanouj toes the line between perfectly smokey and savory, without being bitter and stringy. The familiar sumac topper gives it the perfect lemony lift. @maysalreemus on Facebook
The Crumb Factory’s Cruffin
There are many reasons to love this new bakery in West St. Petersburg, including the amazingly light and non-gooey cinnamon roll and the big inner window with its view of bakers industriously kneading. But the treat that takes the, um, cake is the combination croissant and muffin (distinct from the cronut because it’s baked, not fried) called the Cruffin. Get it with the dulce de leche filling and thank us later. Breakfast and lunch specials, too; get ‘em with the superb sourdough bread. @crumbfactorybakery on Instagram.
MacDinton’s getting alcohol license suspended
One Irish bar that seems to be thriving, however, is MacDinton’s in South Tampa. The location was doing so well, it appeared, that last March in the throes of the pandemic, it totally violated local coronavirus ordinances, which led to the City of Tampa punishing the establishment with a three-day suspension that started on March 18, the day after St. Patrick’s Day when an Irish bar’s staff would probably want to spend a few days not surrounded by guests anyway. Sounds like a win to us. macdintons.com
Winner: Bella's Italian Cafe
Runners-Up: Mazzaro's Italian Market, Pia's Trattoria
See all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.Temple B’nai Israel Jewish Food Festival
Chocolate babka. Pastrami. Corned beef. Matzo ball soup. I’d go on, but it’s making me hungry. This drive-thru food festival in Clearwater happens a couple times a year, giving you a pair of perfect opportunities to stock up on the best kosher eats. Some stuff is local, but they also bring in meats from New York’s Carnegie Deli and cheesecake from Junior’s—the same place P Diddy made his interns walk like a million miles to get a slice. tbiclearwater.org
Anju
When it comes to KFC, there’s only one variety worth pursuing in Tampa Bay: Korean Fried Chicken. Ganchu does it well in the 813, but Anju in St. Petersburg is royalty. It’s queen is Korean-born chef Mee Ae Wolney who graduated from culinary school in Boulder; her KFC is one two “signature dishes” at Anju (along with the bibimbap). As CL food critic Jon Palmer Claridge pointed out, “The juicy, hand cut and battered chicken is available as wings or as K-Pops (bites) tossed in one of two signature sauces, soy garlic or St. Pete heat, with a peanut garnish and a mound of steamed, sticky rice,” and I could eat a pickup truck full of it. anjustpete.com
Winner: Bern's Fine Wines & Spirits
Runners-Up: Tosti's Spirits & Fine Wine, American Spirits & Fine WinesSweet Mama’s
Sweet Mama’s had a little trouble at the get go, but after getting the kinks out, the soft serve ice cream truck is not just succeeding in Tampa Heights but running a second location in Downtown Tampa. “The Cookie Mama” is what I get for a warm, gooey treat. @sweetmamastampa on Instagram
Cacciatore & Sons
The reliable, independently owned food counter-small grocery store combo is sadly not a concept on the rise. It is an evaporating relic; one hesitant grandson or daughter away from disappearing completely. Solidly satisfying and affordable lunch or early dinner offerings aside, Cacciatore & Sons should be recognized with the hope of highlighting this singular and important genre of the food service industry. The meatball sandwich on local Cuban bread is a hunger-seeking missile of deliciousness and its wide selection of housemade antipasto will keep you coming back. While you’re waiting for your order to be completed peruse the fresh produce, delicious dry goods and nice wines offered in the grocery portion of the store. Bonus. cacciatoreandsons.com
Winner: Red Mesa Cantina
Runners-Up: Green Lemon , Casa Tina “Fresh, Healthy, Authentic Mexican"See all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Acropolis Greek Taverna
Runners-Up: Byblos, Baba on CentralSonder Social Club
If you’re feeling too grown-up for milk and cookies, let me introduce Sonder Social Club’s Milk & Cookies cocktail, a combination of oat milk, Sonder Milk, mellow corn whiskey, marzipan, chocolate, banana, and pimento dram only available during the bar’s seasonal popups. Sonder hosted two this year: a Santa-themed shindig in December 2020 followed by a tiki pop-up in June. Milk and cookies was on tap at both. sondersocial.club
Strandhill Public
We all know the tried and true Irish bar aesthetic, wooden walls, thatched roof, old vaguely British memorabilia. What Rory Martin has done here is truly special. Taking the Irish bar into the modern age is no easy feat. Staff it with great bartenders, a killer whiskey selection, and a draft list that puts lesser known Irish craft brews next to the heavy hitters makes for a great place to wind up or turn down every night of the week. With outposts in Brandon and at the Pearl next to Armature Works, you're never too far away from your next after work beer and a shot combo. strandhillpublic.com
See all the winners from Best of the Bay 2021
King Of The Coop
When Joe Dodd pops up on the caller ID, my butthole puckers up. Not just because he’s the duke of Nashville hot chicken in Tampa, but because the call is almost always to tell me about some new location, nonprofit or concept he’s launching as part of what feels like a neverending expansion for his restaurant, King of the Coop. In the last year, CL’s announced new Coops in Wesley Chapel, Westchase and Ybor City, while also sharing news about a new multi-restaurant partnership with Westshore Pizza and Attic Brothers, which’ll serve as KOTC’s anchor. It’s been a pleasure to watch Dodd’s concept fly, and a whole lot of fun to have a bird’s eye view. kingofthecoop.com
Winner: Woven Water Brewing Company
Runners-Up: Magnanimous Brewing , Bay Cannon Beer CompanySee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Gulfport Brewery + Eatery
Runners-Up: Grand Central Brewhouse, Clearwater Brewing CompanySee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Social Roost
Runners-Up: Urban Stillhouse , Casa Santo StefanoSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Urban Stillhouse
Entering Urban Stillhouse your eyes can’t help but be swept up by the grandeur as the windows soar impossibly high. There’s no stained glass here, but the sheer volume of the room is impressive. This is indeed a house of worship, but one dedicated to the art of artisanal bourbon. The menu breaks free of the chains that might normally bind a restaurant worshiping dark spirits; it’s not built around every imaginable beef variation plus Caesar salad and onion soup vs. lobster bisque. Instead, Chef Kenny Tufo offers selective, imaginative fare and lets the kitchen strut its stuff. theurbanstillhouse.com
West Palm Wines
The occasionally sardonic and always knowledgeable and helpful staff here is a local treasure. When not in the back maintaining a massive inventory of vintage wines, it can be found at the front counter listening to jazz, trashing or celebrating classic films and playfully taking the piss out of one and other. Don’t ask for Meomi and you’ll do just fine in here. westpalmwines.com
Bar Chica
Though finding the small speakeasy behind Bodega on Central may be tricky, it’s worth the effort because it’s home to some of the best cocktails around. And ruining the secret by blabbing about this place to all of Tampa Bay doesn’t make this new cocktail enclave any less awesome. It might seem odd to someone not steeped in cocktail history, but tucking a cocktail bar within a Cuban restaurant makes perfect sense. As the U.S. entered prohibition, bartenders in Cuba worked overtime, inventing and reinventing many of the classic cocktails we consume today. Bar Chica serves several of these rum-based Cuban classics. The list includes the Hemingway daiquiri and the lesser-known Hotel Nacional Cocktail. Then there’s the Mary Pickford—a tasty combination of pineapple juice, lime, maraschino cherry liqueur, grenadine and rum named after the Hollywood actress. @thebarchica on Instagram
Ella’s Americana Folk Art Cafe
Never doubt you’ll get a good drink at Ella’s by ordering its take on the classic Old Fashioned (my personal go-to). Strong, well-mixed with Kentucky bourbon, simple syrup, orange and cherry bitters—and the best I’ve had in Tampa so far. Plus, Ella’s staff is great and they’ve got a comfortable set-up both inside and outside that’ll give you the chill vibes you need to truly enjoy the experience. Have a better spot to get an Old Fashioned? HMU. But until then, (don’t) fight me! ellasfolkartcafe.com
El Cap (St. Pete)
Foodies tend to prize innovation and daring (sometimes to the point of foolishness) in a burger. What heady combination of meat(s), exotic cheeses, specialty buns and toppings can a restaurant conjure up? El Cap, on the other hand, values the basics: never-frozen slabs of beef expertly cooked on a grill and, y’know, served inside a bun. Extras (cheese, tomato, lettuce, pickles, et al) cost a little bit more—e.g. grilled onions will set you back an extra 40 cents. We strongly suggest you do it up right with the Daily Double. El Cap is set amid a slew of fast-food joints on a busy section of 4th Street in St. Pete. It offers generous indoor and outdoor seating. When you eat an El Cap burger, you’re tasting not just hearty food, but decades of history. Find El Cap Restaurant on Facebook
Winner: Jackson's
Runners-Up: Salt Shack On The Bay , Sea Sea RidersSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Lemon Grass Thai Kitchen
Runners-Up: Nitally’s Thai Mex , Jasmine ThaiSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: The Lucky Dill Deli
Runners-Up: Mystic Fish , Ozona Blue GrillSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Thai Temple drive-thru
Palm River’s Wat Mongkolratanaram Buddhist Temple is the number one place in Tampa to seek tranquility as you stir your bowl of pho (skinny noodle, please) with a spring roll—but like so many other things, the pandemic took it away. Until last March, that is, when the Wat started drive-thru service complete with rules (masks in your car, cash only), meaning pad thai, chicken, vegetable, and shrimp fresh rolls, empanadas, crab rangoon, and of course, iced thai tea and coffee could all be a part of your Sunday ritual again. wattampainenglish.com
Winner: Noble Crust
Runners-Up: Craft Street Kitchen, Joey's New York Pizzeria and Italian RestaurantSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Madison Avenue Pizza
Runners-Up: Gourmet Pizza Company , New York New YorkSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Meecham Urban Farm
After two years of work, Meacham Farm opened earlier this year in Tampa’s Encore district; punk rocker-turned-urban farmer Travis Malloy’s operation quickly earned deserved praise for the diversity and quality of the produce sprouting from the two acres of organic farm right next to the Bro Bowl. From squash blossoms to pea shoots—with contributions from partner farms further north during our nothing-grows-here summer season—what better way to learn how to cook kohlrabi than with some that got pulled out of the ground that morning? (If you need a recipe, ask Travis.) meachamfarm.com
Winner: Zukku Sushi
Runners-Up: Pacific Counter , Poke BowlSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Pool Bar & Grill
Runners-Up: Hollander Hotel , Ozona Blue GrillSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Buya Ramen
Runners-Up: Ichicoro Ramen , Fusion Street EaterySee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
6 A.M. On 7th
When the mayor announced a competition to name Tampa’s signature cocktail, any drink could have emerged victorious (Salt Life Margarita with Back the Blue curacao, anyone?). But no, judges decided on “6 a.m. on 7th Ave.,” an homage to Tampa’s immigrant roots concocted by Kamran Mir. The cafe con leche-inspired libation uses Cuban rum, Italian liqueur and Grand Marnier as a nod to other European immigrants. It’s served in a styrofoam cup, sometimes with a guava pastry on the side, and, well, I’ll immigrate over to any bar where Mir will make me one. @darthkamran on Instagram
Gulf Coast Sourdough
I know, you could very easily just take a few right turns and safely pull into the parking spots in front of this Seminole Heights bakery and sandwich shop, but there are few things as exhilarating as traveling northbound on Nebraska then cutting a sharp (and illegal?) left knowing that a Gulf Coast Greek turkey, meatball or BST (that’s bacon, spinach, tomato) sandwich waits just beyond the glass windows. Add some flybys, cinnamon rolls or fresh bread and what you have is a meal (almost) worth wrecking your car over. gulfcoastsourdough.com
Rocca
What propels something to greatness? Passion bordering on obsession, keen attention to detail, the element of surprise? Whether shaken or stirred, these qualities make for an impressive cocktail of habits. Chef Bryce Bonsack’s Rocca has it all. Starting in the “food-as-theatre” realm with the riveting handmade mozzarella at your table cart. The heart of Bonsack’s menu is a fixation on pasta, based on extensive travels around Italy to learn authentic, uncompromising techniques. The results are magnificent. Rocco is now an essential pilgrimage for Tampa Bay foodies. (CRITIC’S NOTE: Following the example of the San Pellegrino Worlds 50 Best Awards, BOTB Best Restaurant winners will be retired to Best of the Best status. Rocca joins past winners, The Restorative and Rooster & the Till in this special group.) roccatampa.com
See all the winners from Best of the Bay 2021
Ranchero Tacos
If you haven’t stopped by the new location of this no frills taco truck, drop what you’re doing and get ready for perfection. While it boasts a smaller menu with most of the usual suspects, simple street tacos are the move here. Tortillas are pressed to order and toasted on the flat top, no double up required. Carnitas are juicy and crispy all in one, with the extra unctuousness that comes with a slow cook in fat. The pineapple adorning the al pastor sees some time on the flat top as well, giving it that extra bit of caramelized sweetness. The chorizo comes with a lovely dose of baking spice that keeps it from being too smokey. And if you’re feeling adventurous, the lengua (beef tongue) is so perfectly tender it melts in your mouth. Don’t sleep on the tamales it offers on weekends! rancherotacos.com
Winner: Wicked Oak BBQ
Runners-Up: Dr. BBQ , 4 Rivers SmokehouseSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Gigglewaters
Runners-Up: The Kitchen , Whistle Stop Grill & BarSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Nature's Food Patch
Runners-Up: Whole Foods Market , The Salad StationSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Red Mesa Restaurant
Runners-Up: Bulla Gastrobar , Casa Tina 'Fresh- Healthy- Authentic Mexican’See all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: The Original Crabby Bill's
Runners-Up: Frenchy's , Hog Island Fish CampSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Happy Fish
While land animals can be found on the menu here, creatures of the sea are the polestar of this Peruvian establishment. Its light, fresh ceviche (mixto with fish, octopus and shrimp is the move) with the perfect amount of citrus zip and spiciness and pargo frito (whole fried red snapper) is a must. The goulash-like sudado de pescado, with its fluffy and tender bits of steamed fish, is extraordinarily delicious. happyfishrestaurant.com
Tiki Docks Skyway Bar + Grill
Maybe it’s not a secret to the folks who live there, but for this soon-to-be-transplant to the Skyway Marina District in St. Pete, Tiki Docks Skyway was a revelation. Who knew that just west of 34th Street S, home to every fast food joint known to man, there would be a sprawling indoor-outdoor restaurant perched right on the marina that serves actually good food? The tiki touches are more about tropical flavors and rum drinks than Polynesian kitsch, and the servings are generous, from a truly jumbo shrimp cocktail to a crispy chicken sandwich that puts Mickey D’s to shame. tikidocks.com
Uncle Mince’s World Famous Seitan
Chris Mince has been perfecting his seitan since 2017, basically earning a monopoly on the textured protein in the Tampa Bay area. His product can be found at various spots like Vegan International Co., Cider Press Cafe, and the Vegan Halal Cart. It’s cruelty free and delicious. Get some. @unclemincesworldfamousseit on Facebook
Winner: 3 Daughters Hard Seltzer
Runners-Up: Funky Buddha Premium Seltzer, Cigar City SeltzerSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Ella’s Americana Folk Art Cafe
Runners-Up: Rooster & the Till , Ichicoro RamenSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Tom Murray (Shuffle)
Mother’s Day had me at Shuffle for a casual brunch that left me thinking way too much about the shakshuka special I had. It had tater tots baked in! I don’t know what else was in it, besides eggs and tomatoes, but I don’t need to know. I just need it in my belly again. shuffletampa.com
Winner: Rollin' Oats
Runners-Up: SOHO Juice Co. , Sweet Soul SoHoSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Jen Bingham at Cru Cellars
Runners-Up: Kristie Grey at Flor Fina , Andrew Harris at RoccaSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Bern's Steak House
Runners-Up: Stone Soup Company , Frenchy's RockawaySee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: The Mill
Runners-Up: Ella's Americana Folk Art Cafe , Noble CrustSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: The Black Pearl
Runners-Up: Council Oak Steaks & Seafood, Salt Rock Grill
See all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Ferg's Sports Bar
Runners-Up: Hattricks Tavern , Eddie's Bar & GrillSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Red Mesa Restaurant
Runners-Up: Social Roost, The Mill
See all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Bern's Steak House
Runners-Up: Council Oak Steaks & Seafood, Charley's Steak House
See all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Hole N One
Diet schmiet. Especially when it comes to the best donuts in town that are still fresh and warm when you buy them, even if you roll out of bed at 10 a.m. I prefer the maple ones myself. I only go to “Number 3,” but there are locations in Seffner and Plant City if you’re further out. Find Hole In One Donut at Facebook
Boozy Pig vending machine
I don’t know why you’d try to avoid a face-to-face encounter with your local butcher, but maybe the chop shop is closed and you’re having a hankering for beef jerky, steaks, ground, burgers, fresh and smoked sausages, or bacon. Enter Boozy Pig’s meat vending machine near Tampa’s Oakford Park. All the animal products are in there, just make sure to start your charcoal before heading out to grab your meat. @theboozypig on Instagram
Bright Ice
When Bright Ice opened at the busy St. Petersburg corner of 37th Street and 5th Avenue N more than two years ago, locals rejoiced. Now that its savvy owners, Steve Garrahan and Kurt Drake, have expanded to Pinellas Park and Water Street Tampa, the rest of Tampa Bay is discovering their Deepest Darkest Chocolate Secret — a flavor that’s every bit as addictive as it sounds. (But then again, so is Lemon with Crystallized Ginger. And Roasted Strawberries with Brown Sugar and Balsamic. And Warm Vanilla. And… need I go on?) brighticeisnice.com
Chill Bros. Scoop Shop
But sweet scoops are spreading far and wide in Tampa, too. Last year’s Best of the Bay winner for “Best Place To End A Date” will soon offer more places to do just that. As of publishing, Chill Bros. Scoop Shop, which first opened in Ybor City, has opened a second spot in South Tampa, plus plans to open at the Epicurean Hotel and Water street. Expansion has no chill for these brothers. chillbros.com
Winner: Bulla Gastrobar
Runners-Up: Ceviche Tapas Bar and Restaurant, Hawkers Asian Street Food
See all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Gulfport Brewery’s pride flight
If you like sour beer and rainbows, Gulfport Brewery’s Pride flight was pure heaven. It was also the perfect break from walking up and down Gulfport’s Beach Boulevard during Gulfport Pride. I met most of the town as I sat in Gulfport Brewery’s beer garden with my tray full of colorful sour beers. Everyone wanted to know what we were drinking, and we were happy to tell them. As I told those walking past, every beer in that Pride flight was delicious, but my favorite was the Key lime pie beer. Toft has a real gift for making dessert-inspired sours. That Key lime pie beer (Pride Green), along with the Cherry Cheesecake Berliner Toft brewed in collaboration with Crooked Thumb’s Kenjiro Tomita, were my favorite local brews this year. gulfport-brewing.com
Winner: TeBella Tea Company
Runners-Up: The Spice and Tea Exchange, Blush Tea and Coffee
See all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Red Mesa Cantina
Runners-Up: Casa Tina '"Fresh, Healthy, Authentic Mexican,” VIP MexicanSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Lanna thai
The strip-mall facade of Lanna Thai may be unprepossessing, but its interior is elegant and the welcome warm. The menu, in the tradition of many Asian restaurants, is vast, but here that variety is a strength, not a drawback. The sushi is beautifully prepared, the basics (like a flavorful pad thai) are well-executed, and in special dishes like duck seafood hot pepper (duck, shrimp, scallops and squid sauteed with peppers and basil), the individual ingredients maintain a crisp identity in a subtle sauce. lannathaiandsushistpete.com
Winner: Lemon Grass Thai Kitchen
Runners-Up: Jasmine Thai , 9Bangkok Thai and Sushi RestaurantSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Jesus Bravo’s quesabirria tacos
We all remembered very quickly how much we loved dining in restaurants as soon as we weren’t allowed to. The dishes stacked up, the delivery got old and there weren’t many exciting new options that weren’t ghost kitchens cooking uninspired food. Enter Jesus Bravo, the taco master grinding and nixtamalizing his own corn for tortillas. The quesabirria tacos on offer here are a glutinous mashup of Oaxacan cheese and braised beef, huge flavors in tiny packets ready to be dipped in an oh so flavorful consomme. White onion and cilantro help balance the richness of these made to order tacos, which require you to order ahead. Don’t skip the conchas either, wonderful Mexican sweet breads in your choice of chocolate or vanilla. Plans to move into a food truck are underway, so keep a lookout! @te_invito_tampa on Instagram
Winner: La V Vietnamese Fusion
Runners-Up: Pho Quyen , Lotus Vegan RestaurantSee all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
La Vid Fine Wines & Vinoteca
Tampa native and sommelier Victor Manuel’s ode to the Iberian peninsula boasts an impressive selection of wines. While the shop includes bottles from all over the world, it’s the spotlight on Spanish and Portuguese wines that makes La Vid special and unique. After years of working in many of the finer eating and drinking establishments in the Bay area and abroad, Victor opened La Vid Fine Wines and Vinoteca in the fall of 2020. Inside the well-curated shop, your experience is not limited to retail; as several (if not nearly all) of his carefully selected wines are available to enjoy on premise at the bar along with delicious meats, cheeses and sundries. lavidtampa.com
Florida State Fair pickle pizza
When the Florida State Fair released its food lineup in April, it was full of easy-to-agree-on treats (Amish blueberry and cream doughnut, anyone?). But also on the lineup were food items that could divide a family quicker than debating the merits of the Jan. 6 insurrection. The loudest culprit? Dill pickle pizza with a white garlic sauce base and mozzarella cheese, plus dill and ranch dressing garnish. In the words of CL contributor Stephanie Powers, “Either you love pickles or you’re a fucking weirdo.” floridastatefair.com
Winner: The Urban Stillhouse
Runners-Up: Copper Shaker, Gigglewaters
See all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Lolita’s Wine Market
Runners-Up: Cru Cellars, Cooper's Hawk
See all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Ferg's Sports Bar & Grill
Runners-Up: Riveter's, Hattrick’s Tavern
See all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Winner: Flor Fina at Hotel Haya
Runners-Up: Tampa Bay Brewing Company, The Bricks
See all winners from Best of the Bay 2021.
Cafe Ponte
When I first returned to Tampa Bay in 2010, researching the best fine dining in the region was at the top of my to-do list. I knew the long time stalwarts, but was keen to see who was now turning out dishes to take your breath away. Everywhere I turned, the answer was Chris Ponte’s eponymous flagship in a strip mall near where Ulmerton and I-275 collide. I celebrated a milestone birthday there where even a pal from Manhattan gasped. But the economics of the pandemic took a toll. Luckily, the sibling phoenix rises soon with the opening of Ponte Tampa. cafeponte.com and pontetampa.com
Urban Stillhouse pea soup
The kitchen hits a home run with this fabulous chilled summer pea soup. It’s a heady, sophisticated mix of stunning flavors. A trio of tender, smoked diver sea scallops swim in the creamy emulsion. Chef Kenny Tufo adds accents of bits of coconut, an aromatic spiral of turmeric oil, a dusting of smoky char (source unknown) and a scattering of wispy marigold petals which charm the eye in bright shades of intense yellow and electric orange. It’s a triumph on every level. You’ll have to wait till next summer, but don’t miss this one. theurbanstillhouse.com
Four Green Fields closing
If thatched roof Irish bars are your thing, there was no more authentic place than the original Four Green Fields on Platt Street. After 28 years, the bar closed last December, and while a new location is supposed to be coming to Channelside, the Curtis Hixon location (and parking lot that now sits where Four Green Fields used to be) leaves a Guinness-pint-sized hole in my colcannon-clogged heart. fourgreenfields.com
Coney Island Sandwich Shop
It’s delicious and cheap and a last stronghold of unironic diner-style eating. Sadly the iconic Coney Island Sandwich Shop is one of the many businesses that took a hit during the pandemic, and as these words are being written the future of Coney Island is uncertain. To eat here meant more than enjoying a delicious dog or burger. The restaurant’s unwavering reverence for tradition gave one a chance to sit and experience another era. If it winds up permanently closing, it will be a great loss for the area. Find Coney Island Hot Dogs on Facebook